How much more money could you earn if you had a financial adviser? Here's what research shows
By Andrew Shilling
There can be a financial advantage to an adviser in some circumstances, but it often depends on what type of investor you are.
MarketWatch Picks highlights items we think you'll find useful; we are independent of the MarketWatch newsroom. We earn a commission from some links in our articles. Learn more
Managing your own portfolio might seem more financially savvy than paying an adviser - and in many cases it absolutely is - but going it alone can sometimes cost you, research shows. During extreme market downturns, managed accounts deliver an 18% advantage over do-it-yourself investing, according to a new report from Morningstar. That means that in the absolute worst-case market scenarios, managed accounts resulted in more money at 65 than DIY portfolios 99% of the time.
Vanguard's ongoing "Advisor's Alpha" framework estimates that professional guidance adds up to 3% in net returns annually. And 401(k) data from Aon Hewitt and Financial Engines shows that investors using managed options historically outpace DIY peers by 3.32% a year due to better diversification.
To be sure, there's plenty of robust research showing the opposite. Indeed, decades of historical data show that low-cost, passive index funds frequently outperform actively managed accounts, largely due to the drag of advisory fees. Morningstar studies this annually, and in its year-end 2025 study, it found that "actively managed mutual funds and exchange-traded funds struggled to outperform their average passive peer in 2025. Just 38% survived and beat their asset-weighted average passive composite." This is often how these reports go.
With that in mind, why and when might advisers provide an advantage? "One possible explanation is that DIY portfolios may be less diversified or have asset allocations that are less appropriate for participants' ages," the Morningstar researchers note. Another reason an adviser could be an advantage: "Most people make poor decisions at the key moments in the market," says Michael Walstedt, a certified financial planner, founder of Reliant Wealth Advisory. "A high-quality financial adviser makes sure you aren't the person panicking out of your stocks near the lows." (Looking for an adviser? You can use this free tool that can match you to a fiduciary adviser, from our ad partner SmartAsset, as well as resources like NAPFA and the CFP Board.)
But with adviser fees often coming in at 1% or sometimes more, it's not always the right move for everyone. Here's who an adviser might make sense for.
You're prone to panic
Watching an account balance decline week after week can understandably create high levels of unrest. Part of what sets a professional money manager apart from a DIYer is a third-person perspective, says Melissa Caro, a CFP and founder of My Retirement Network. "Eventually, investors may reach a point where they simply want that discomfort to stop," Caro says. "They feel compelled to do something, whether that's selling investments, moving to cash, or reducing contributions, without fully considering the long-term consequences."
Eileen C. Olson, a CFP and founder of Emerald Wealth, points to halting 401(k) contributions as the most common and damaging mistake investors make when markets fall. "That's exactly when your dollars buy the most," Olson says. "Think of it as stocks being on sale. You wouldn't stop shopping during a big sale, so why stop investing? Pausing turns a temporary loss into a permanent shortfall."
Caro says: "Sometimes an adviser's most important role is simply helping a frightened client work through their emotions. Those conversations that may feel more like therapy than financial planning can prevent costly decisions. An adviser can help clients reconnect with their long-term goals at precisely the moment when fear is narrowing their perspective."
You don't have the emotional discipline to stay the course
Despite best intentions, reactive behavior can lead investors to do the exact wrong thing at the worst possible time. Walstedt says the real problem may be lack of emotional discipline among some investors: "They bet heavily at the highs, when sentiment can't get any better, and end up holding losing positions. Or they turn super bearish and sell everything during a drawdown, right when they should be thinking about buying."
DIY investors often compound their errors by selling near the bottom in a panic-driven attempt to protect their remaining cash - locking in losses and ensuring they miss the inevitable rebound. Olson says these reactive moves are frequently the result of portfolios built too aggressively for the investor's actual risk tolerance, combined with the habit of obsessively checking daily balances, which magnifies the emotional pressure to act.
You're a trend chaser
Alex Caswell, a CFP, founder and CEO of Wealth Script Advisors, says the groundwork for many of these mistakes is often laid during bull markets, when retail investors may feel empowered to chase hot trends. Because it's natural to gravitate toward high-volatility investments, dabbling in this field creates much steeper, more terrifying drops when the market turns. "When the market takes a downturn, they are experiencing the greatest amount of volatility in comparison to a diversified portfolio," Caswell says.
You tinker too much
Many DIY investors mistakenly believe active portfolio management requires constant tinkering. In reality, professional money managers operate within a strict, disciplined process and understand that doing nothing is often the smartest investment decision. For everyday investors, bridging the gap between knowing they should hold steady and actually doing it sometimes requires an outside voice.
You simply want a pro to help
Some investors simply want someone else to make investing decisions for them - and to create a solid plan for how they will meet their goals. Olson advises investors to make a concrete plan during calm times that includes how to deal with a market crash, so the decisions are already made before panic sets in. "Good investing isn't about never feeling that," Olson says. "It's about having a system that keeps you from acting on it." You can use this free tool that can match you to a fiduciary adviser, from our ad partner SmartAsset, as well as resources like NAPFA and the CFP Board.
-Andrew Shilling
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
11-17-26 1330ET
Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.
Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.
Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.
Popular

5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings

7 Undervalued Stocks That Crushed Earnings

This Newly Undervalued Stock Has Plenty of Growth Ahead

Are These Riskier Bond ETFs Worth the Higher Yields?

