5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings
Plus, what to know ahead of Nvidia’s results.
Key Takeaways
- Why artificial intelligence stocks surged after CoreWeave’s CRWV earnings.
- Economic data to watch this week.
- Key considerations ahead of Nvidia’s NVDA upcoming third-quarter results.
- Why we’ll be watching earnings reports from Home Depot HD, Lowe’s LOW, Walmart WMT, and Target TGT.
- Berkshire Hathaway BRK.A/BRK.B is up 16% over three months. Is it a buy?
- Why defense stocks like Lockheed Martin LMT sold off after the midterms.
- Stock picks: what to buy after earnings.
In this new episode of The Morning Filter podcast, co-hosts Dave Sekera and Sarah Hansen discuss last week’s market action, including the rebound in artificial intelligence stocks that followed CoreWeave’s latest earnings report. They also cover the runup in the 10-year Treasury yield and the implications of October’s hotter-than-expected Consumer Price Index Report.
With all eyes on Nvidia, Sekera and Hansen cover what investors need to know ahead of the chip giant’s third-quarter earnings results. They also preview upcoming earnings from consumer stalwarts Home Depot, Lowe’s, Walmart, and Target.
Sekera and Hansen answer an audience question about a recent selloff in defense stocks: Why did these names fall after the midterm elections if they have government contracts locked in for decades? They wrap up the episode with five stocks that look like buys after earnings. Tune in to hear why Alphabet GOOGL made the list, even after its recent stumble.
Got a question for Dave? Send it to themorningfilter@morningstar.com.
Transcript
Hansen: Hello, and welcome to The Morning Filter podcast. I’m Sarah Hansen with Morningstar, sitting in for Susan Dziubinski, who will return next week. But for this one last Monday, I’m here with Morningstar chief US market strategist Dave Sekera to talk about key takeaways for investors in today’s market, what to keep on your radar this week, some new Morningstar research, and of course a few stock ideas. Good morning, Dave. How are you doing? It’s great to see you.
Sekera: Oh, good morning. I have to admit, though, I think I’m on day six right now of having caught this—it’s either the cold or the flu—whatever’s going around. I tell you what, man, this one really has knocked me down for a couple of days, but here we are. Let’s get going. Good to go.
Market Recap
Hansen: OK, we’re going to take it easy on you today. Not like there’s any news to talk about, but we will make sure you can get some rest this afternoon. All right, let’s start with a recap of the market last week. Never a dull moment. What were the takeaways for investors?
Sekera: Oh, I think that’s the understatement of the day. It was just definitely a roller coaster of a week and I think the highs and the lows and how the market reacted and traded probably aren’t necessarily captured in the index levels. But what it tells me, and I think the real takeaway is, in my mind, the lack of leadership that I saw in the marketplace, the lack of confidence that I saw by investors generally tells me that I don’t think the market has a very strong confidence or view on how AI is going to play out in 2027.
In fact, I think that 2027 might be the make it or break it year for artificial intelligence. Really, what was going on was that we saw traders rotating between risk-on and risk-off. Really, it was just the significant rotation either into all of the AI stocks in particular whenever there was some good news that came out. When there was some bad news that came out, everyone tried getting back out again at the same point in time. I think we’re just set up right now to see heightened volatility for the next few months. I think until we get fourth-quarter earnings and 2027 guidance coming out late January, end of February, I think you’re going to see a lot more of this type of action.
In fact, it looks like that’s what we’re seeing this a.m. before the market opened. Last I checked, futures were down 0.6%. When I went to bed last night, they looked to be in the green. Like I said, I think there’s going to be a lot of this back and forth until people get a much better firm handle on what they really think 2027 is going to shape up to look like, both in terms of new capex, new investing in artificial intelligence, and really looking for those signs in 2027 that companies are going to be able to utilize AI to start generating that revenue and those earnings they’re going to need to support all the capex spending that we’ve seen over the past couple of years.
Hansen: What did you see in the bond market?
Sekera: We talked about the prior week, how the 10-year had backed off; it hit 5%, and I said if it didn’t keep 5% or below, that it would probably end up looking to gravitate toward 5.25% thereafter. I know the bond market did weaken over the course of the week. Now, with futures being down this morning, it looks like the 10-year is better by a couple of basis points; it might be at like 5.12, 5.13 this morning, but I’m still very concerned at this point that we could see a weaker bond market in the short term. I think the market’s going to want to try and test that 5.25% area again. If it doesn’t hold that 5.25%, then it’s off to 5.5%. As those rates continue to weaken, if that’s what we see, that of course is just going to be another headline risk and more volatility for stocks.
Hansen: Makes sense. And the hot CPI data we saw last week probably isn’t going to help the bond market.
Sekera: No, no. I’m just taking a look at the implied probabilities, and the CME FedWatch tool just shows that the market is definitely pricing in at least one hike, one 25-basis-point hike here at the December meeting. I think there’s even a small probability that they could go 50. I highly doubt that they’re going to go 50 basis points, but the market’s certainly pricing in a lock on 25.
Retail Data on Deck
Hansen: OK, sounds good. Let’s look ahead to this week in the economy. Anything we should be watching for in terms of data?
Sekera: Not really. I mean, it’s a pretty quiet week. The only thing that I’d probably end up taking a look at is going to be retail sales, both the headline and the core number. And really, the biggest reason is just because of the time of year we’re in. I just want to see if there are any indications there of either a strengthening or weakening consumer as we go into the all-important holiday sales season.
Earnings Watch: NVDA
Hansen: OK. Now, the name on everyone’s mind: Let’s start with earnings. We have a very big report this week, the one company that Wall Street’s watching extremely closely, especially after a dramatic CEO ouster in the middle of last week. Let’s talk about Nvidia NVDA. So, we cut our fair value estimate pretty significantly following that news from $310 to $250. What’s Morningstar’s take on the stock? What prompted that move, and what’s going to be most important in their results when they report this week?
Sekera: Of course. Let’s actually address the fair value cut first because I think it’s instructive to look at exactly what our analysts did and how that led to that fair value decrease. He actually didn’t make any change to his short-term forecasts. If you look at what he’s forecasting over the next five years, our compound annual growth rate for revenue over those five years is still 36%. He’s still forecasting $400 billion in revenue for fiscal 2027, growing to over a trillion dollars by 2031. That’s unchanged. Just to put $1 trillion of revenue into perspective, I was looking it up over the weekend. Comparatively, if you look at Amazon.com AMZN or Walmart WMT, the two largest retailers in the United States, I mean their revenue right now is only $700 billion each. We’d be looking for more revenue coming from just Nvidia by 2031 than either Amazon or Walmart is able to produce today.
What actually changed to drive that fair value decrease was that he lowered his longer-term growth rates. I think the thought process there is without the CEO who’s really driven the company to where it is today, who’s been such a visionary for artificial intelligence and has been such a proponent of growing AI as much as it has, and really a lot of different areas of AI, not just necessarily the hardware, but also being involved in a lot of the other aspects of the business. We lowered those long-term growth rates that drove a lot of the decrease in the fair value. But then, in order to capture the heightened risk that we expect now, he also increased the cost of equity in our discounted cash flow model. That cost of equity, he brought that up to 10.7% from 9.8%. Because of what we’re seeing going on in the credit markets, he also increased their cost of debt because credit spreads have been widening out here as well. Between all of that, you increase your weighted average cost of capital, and of course a higher discount rate decreases the present value of cash flows today. That’s what drove all of that.
Now, the conference call, in and of itself, I mean, to some degree, it’s all going to be about trying to understand what the impact of the company, and really the entire AI space, is going to be after the CEO got forced out. Now, in my opinion, I think it’s probably going to be a very disappointing call for a lot of people because there’s going to be a lot of questions. They’re just not going to be in a position to be able to answer or just aren’t going to want to answer.
The first question to me when the numbers come out is, are they going to provide quarterly guidance like they typically do, or are they going to decline to offer guidance? I can make the case for both why they should or they shouldn’t, but I think the market will probably be very unhappy if they don’t continue to keep offering guidance. I think the other big question is until whoever that new CEO is going to be, until that’s announced, what really is Nvidia’s focus here over the next couple months, maybe even next couple of quarters, depending on how long it takes for that new CEO, for them to find who it is and to bring them on board. Of course, then that new CEO also needs time really just to get up to speed on the business and then decide what, if anything, they want to make changes in the business themselves.
The other questions are going to be: Is there an impact on future equity investments in customers? Is there going to be an impact on future financing deals? We’ve talked about, to quite a large degree, the circular financing of them lending money to their clients, the clients then using that money in order to be able to buy their products, how they’ve made equity investments in a lot of their clients as well. A lot of discussion as far as whether that’s something that was going to get pushed back, or is that something that maybe just doesn’t happen going forward, or is it still going to be game on for doing those kinds of things?
Lastly, I think there’s going to be a lot of questions about investigations as to whether or not Nvidia is supplying semiconductors to customers really with the intent to evade US export restrictions. I think that’s going to be ongoing for quite a while as they do those investigations. I think there’s going to be a lot of questions regarding the pace of data center development following the democratic sweep of Congress. I don’t know if they have any answers for that just yet, but I think that’s going to be certainly questions people are going to want answers to.
And then, of course, once we do have that new CEO coming in and taking over, I don’t know if it’s an outsider, would they then take that opportunity to try and reset some of the expectations for the company lower, try and bring down what some of the long-term growth expectations are? Of course, if you’re a new CEO, you want to have your own imprimatur on exactly what you think you can and can’t do. I think there’s a high probability that if I’m a new CEO, especially coming in from the outside, the thing I want to do is underpromise so I have a much easier ability to overdeliver. If those reset expectations are lower, that’s also something that, when the new CEO comes in, could hit the stock.
Hansen: Just a few questions for Nvidia to deal with this week. The market is so focused on them every quarter, but this quarter seems sort of highly unusual with just how much pressure and how much focus is going to be on this call. Is that fair to say?
Sekera: Yeah. And I mean, to some degree, I just don’t think they’re going to be able to answer any of these questions. I think the market’s going to be disappointed, but the market also has to understand this has all come about so fast that they’re just not going to have any answers. I don’t know. I think this is going to be a very tough conference call. I certainly wouldn’t want to try and be the CFO of Nvidia trying to take a lot of Q&A on this call; that’s for sure.
Hansen: No. Are you worried? I’ll put you on the spot for just one minute. Are you worried about a lot of volatility? Could we see some major selling action around this call, or do you think the market is kind of willing to look long-term here and past the short-term questions that we’ve been talking about?
Sekera: That’s really just an impossible question to try and answer. I think it all really just depends on: Do they provide guidance, or do they not provide guidance? If they provide guidance, is it going to be with expectations or higher than expectations? If they provide lower-than-expected guidance, then yeah, there’s going to be a lot of volatility to the downside. Like you said, if they don’t provide any guidance at all, I think the market will certainly understand why they don’t, but they’re also going to be guided or disappointed that they don’t. I don’t know. We shall see. I guess I should probably go take a look at the options market. It’d be interesting to see what the implied volatility is in options right now for the week.
Earnings Watch: PANW
Hansen: OK. Stay tuned. Let’s move on to the next one on our docket with software stock Palo Alto Networks PANW. What will you want to hear there when they report? Hopefully nothing so exciting as what we’re hearing from Nvidia.
Sekera: Yeah. Now, the stock has been under pressure since its early October highs. It got so high that it was a 2-star-rated stock for a bit of time, but now it’s traded down enough. I think it’s a little bit above our $300 fair value, so it puts it kind of right smack in the middle of that 3-star territory. I think the biggest questions are going to be one, just what is the annualized run rate, or what they call the ARR, of their next-generation security? And just trying to understand how AI is changing demand for security and how they’re able to keep up with that change in demand. I think to some degree you’re going to want specific questions about how much of cyberspending is directly tied to AI deployments overall, as a lot of these new models are being brought online. I think people want to see what the adoption trends for AI security offerings are.
I think they want to understand whether enterprises are increasing their security budgets because of the generative AI cybersecurity risks. And then lastly, what are they seeing as far as demand from hyperscalers and large enterprises who are building out AI infrastructure, and if they’re still getting all of that new demand as those data centers are being brought online?
Earnings Watch: HD and LOW
Hansen: Great. All right, let’s switch gears to the consumer a little bit. We’ll also have Home Depot HD and Lowe’s LOW reporting this week. What will you be looking for there?
Sekera: Yeah. As far as where the stocks are trading, Home Depot is a 3-star-rated stock. I think it’s trading a little bit above our $325 fair value. Lowe’s is a 4-star-rated stock, trades at 11% discount, so that’s just enough to get that into that 4-star territory, but not necessarily really cheap at this point in time. I think the big question is, has the home improvement cycle started? Has it finally started to turn the corner, or are consumers still delaying a lot of those large discretionary projects for their home improvement?
I think it’s also going to be interesting to see what the impact of declining existing home sales is. That number came out relatively recently and was a lot lower than what was expected because, of course, when you have homes turn over, people move into new homes, they want to paint, they want to do new projects, to fix up the house that they wanted to take a look at. If we have existing home sales going down and new-home sales have also been very disappointing, I think that’s going to be a big headwind for their business for quite a while.
Earnings Watch: WMT and TGT
Hansen: OK. In that same vein, let’s talk about Walmart WMT and Target TGT, which we’ll also get this week. You mentioned the upcoming holiday season, and how healthy or not healthy the consumer is looking. What should we keep in mind ahead of those two results?
Sekera: Yeah, and of course, what we’ve talked about with both of these stocks in the past is just how expensive they are. Depending on what the results and the guidance and any commentary they have about the holiday sales season, I do think both of these stocks are at risk of what could be pretty substantial selloffs. Walmart is a 1-star-rated stock and trades at a 56% premium to our fair value. That company trades at 39 times earnings. It’s just way too high of a multiple for what is essentially an everyday low price retailer. That’s one that, if you had any multiple compression and had any kind of disappointment in earnings, that one I think could gap down pretty significantly. Target, not as overvalued. It’s a 23% premium, a 2-star-rated stock. Now, that one trades at only 17 times earnings, so people might think, eh, that’s not necessarily all that expensive in today’s market, but I would note that we just don’t forecast any real growth in that stock whatsoever.
As you mentioned, what are the changes in consumer spending trends, spending by income level, signs of consumer trade-down behavior, signs of discretionary purchase changes—any of that, especially going into the holiday sales season, is going to have a leverage effect on these stocks.
Neocloud Earnings: CRWV and NBIS
Hansen: OK. Important trends to watch for two kind of expensive names, it sounds like. All right, let’s move on to some new Morningstar research, starting with our take on earnings from CoreWeave CRWV and Nebius Group NBIS. We talked about these at length for the past two weeks. They are these two neocloud stocks at the center of the AI buildout, and they’ve been extremely volatile. They’ve been selling off, recovering, selling off, recovering—a roller-coaster ride, to be sure. What did the market think of their earnings last week, and what does Morningstar think?
Sekera: Well, and it kind of goes back to the beginning of the show when we were just talking about the lack of confidence that we’re seeing and the lack of leadership in the market overall, and certainly seeing that in these two stocks specifically. Interestingly, CoreWeave came out with their numbers. It was actually fundamentally pretty good. They saw a 42% increase in revenue, margin expanded by 500 basis points. The backlog is increasing, management increased guidance, and the stock actually had a pretty good bounce initially, but it also is interesting too. If you look at the bond market, we’ve talked about how CoreWeave bonds were trading in, I think, the upper 70s and were yielding well over 15%. Those bonds also took a little bit of a trade up, but yet both of those pretty quickly thereafter gave up some of the bounce. I mean, the CoreWeave bonds right now are still trading at 14.8%. The bond market is still pricing in a very high probability of default, cumulative probability of default over the next three to five years for that company.
That just tells me that with CoreWeave, the bond market is essentially closed for them trying to raise any new money. Of course, we know this company is free cash flow negative and that they need future funding to be able to continue to build out the data centers that they want to build out. Any new money, I think, is going to have to come from equity, and any equity raises that they do is going to end up causing a lot of dilution in the equity valuation, and that ended up leading us to cut our fair value a little bit.
Now, Nebius, and this is one, if you remember, has been a sell recommendation a couple of times. I think the most recent time we recommended selling it was the Aug. 10 episode of The Morning Filter. Now, in this case, they did disappoint the market. They lowered their revenue guidance. They increased their guidance for capex spending for 2027. So, lower revenue, higher spending; that’s just a toxic combination for a growth story, and we saw that being taken out on that stock price. I think you have to remember, for both of these companies, the valuation of those stocks is based on free cash flow that’s not until far out into the future. Taking a quick look at our model, we don’t think CoreWeave’s going to be free cash flow positive until 2031, and Nebius is not going to be free cash flow positive until 2030. Any small changes in when that free cash flow, if it gets pushed out even further, is going to have leverage-negative effects on its valuation.
Earnings Recap: AMAT
Hansen: Sure. Yeah, with these AI stocks, it seems like it all comes down to that question of when are we going to start to see some profits? When are we going to be free cash flow positive? Kind of a show me the money story, maybe. All right, let’s talk about Applied Materials AMAT, which we previewed last week. What was your takeaway from their results?
Sekera: Just reading through our analyst note, he noted he thought they had pretty strong fourth-quarter performance; 2027 guidance came in above our model. From his point of view, that still indicates just a huge amount of growth in 2027, specifically in their leading-edge logic, DRAM, and advanced packaging products. We raised our fair value to $570 from $520. Just taking a quick look at our model, we are modeling in 40% revenue growth for 2027. I think we probably have pretty good visibility into that growth number for this upcoming year, but then he dials it back to 20% in 2028, 14% in 2029, and then a normalized run rate thereafter. Stock only trades at 19 times our 2027 earnings estimate, but yet we’re still looking for a five-year compound annual growth rate for earnings of 25%. This one still looks pretty attractive in our view.
Earnings Recap: BRK.A/BRK.B
Hansen: Great. OK. Berkshire Hathaway BRK.A/BRK.B, we’ll get this week. Oh, we got last week; I’m sorry. This one feels like a totally different universe than the other AI stocks we’ve been talking about. It’s like a whole different market. While those tech stocks and the AI trade have been kind of churning, Berkshire has been steadily climbing pretty smoothly, something like 16% over the past three months. What was your take on its third-quarter results, what do they need to do to keep that momentum going, and are they expensive? Are they too expensive now?
Sekera: Let’s cut to the chase first. So, is it too expensive? Probably. It’s currently a 2-star-rated stock, trades at a 15% premium to fair value. As you noted, I think this has just become a safe place for people to hide some money. It’s probably the ultimate value stock. It’s not going to be impacted all that much by what happens with AI. I think it’s really just been more of that flight from AI or that anti-AI trade. Now, as you mentioned, the stock’s up, I think, over 17% year to date. Almost all of that came just since the beginning of October.
The question here for investors is, is it time to maybe peel a little bit off? That one’s hard to answer. I mean, it’s Berkshire. You own it for a reason. You own it as a long-term investor. This isn’t one that you’re looking to trade around. Maybe you peel a little bit off, lock in some of that profit. If the market does end up taking a hit to the downside, like anything else, correlation to the downside always goes to one. I’d expect even Berkshire probably to sell off a little bit. Maybe you can reload at that point in time. But again, that’s more of a trading game than it is necessarily a longer-term investment game. As far as the fundamentals in and of themselves, I’d say slightly better than expected, but really nothing here that would change us to really make any big changes to our fair value.
NRG: Buy After Earnings?
Hansen: OK, makes sense. While Berkshire is the anti-AI trade, we also have NRG Energy NRG, which is very much tied up in the AI boom. This is a company that provides power to data centers. It is down, unlike Berkshire, about 40% for the year. It’s also right in the middle of this ongoing debate among lawmakers in Washington about restricting data center development, which is something that kind of clearly touched a nerve with the market over the past couple of weeks. What did Morningstar think of NRG Energy? Oh, Dave, you’re muted. I missed your first …
Sekera: Sorry about that.
Hansen: No worries.
Sekera: Now I’m trying to keep the mute going just so if I’m coughing, I’m not coughing in everybody’s ear while we’re making it through our way through today’s podcast. NRG is one of the largest retail energy providers in the US, but it’s also one of the largest US independent power producers. This is one of those stocks that just took off to the upside. Everyone knows that we need a lot more electricity to power all these data centers. AI chips require multiple times more electricity than traditional computing chips, but this is one that we caution that it ran way too far to the upside. It was well overvalued, well into 1-star territory for quite a while. It’s now fallen, I think, about 50% from its February high. In fact, it’s now round-tripped its entire gain over the past two years. Finally fallen enough. It’s a 3-star-rated stock. Nothing all that interesting actually going on here.
Management reaffirmed its EBITDA guidance for the year. They came in with some updated 2027 EBITDA guidance, but both of those were already within our ranges, so that’s already contemplated in our fair value and our outlook. Nothing interesting here now that it’s finally fallen 50% and given up two years’ worth of gains.
Defense Stock Dip
Hansen: OK. Sounds like a status quo there for NRG. Moving on to our question of the week. As a reminder, if you have a question for us, you can reach us via email at themorningfilter@morningstar.com. Today’s question comes from Robert, who wants to know about defense stocks and why defense stocks like Lockheed Martin LMT got hit during the selloff after the midterms, even though they have government contracts signed for decades, which would seem to be kind of confidence-building for investors. What was the market worried about there, and what’s the outlook for these stocks?
Sekera: Yeah, and to some degree, I think it’s probably a lot of overreaction from negative sentiment in the marketplace. To some degree too, they’re also just kind of getting whipped around with the on-again, off-again AI trade. I think there are a couple of different factors that are going on. But first of all, I think following the midterms, everybody knows that the original kind of Trump $1.5 trillion defense budget is definitely not going to happen. I think people already kind of knew that we’re probably never going to get there, but this gives kind of that final nail in the coffin as far as being able to get to that type of number.
I think that the passage of any new defense budgets is probably largely in question now as far as what’s going to be included, what’s not going to be included. So a lot of uncertainty there. You’re going to end up requiring continuing resolutions, maybe some stopgap funding measures. With that uncertainty going on, I think a lot of defense contractors may end up kind of slowing some of the development work that they might be working on now until they get better clarity going forward. There could be some slight slowing in the industry overall, but we don’t necessarily see that enough to be anything that would change our fair values here in the short term. Let me just take a quick drink of coffee here. We’ll see if my voice can make it through the end of the podcast today.
Hansen: You can do it! Or skip to your takeaways if you need to.
Sekera: Yeah. Just thinking about the defense stocks in and of themselves, like Lockheed Martin, I think that’s the one that people were questioning the most, and I think that’s the one that actually sold off the most initially. I mean, that’s really the bellwether for the defense industry. I think one of the biggest benefits that that stock was getting from the Trump administration was a quadrupling of the missile volume that still has yet to get funded, so I think people might be pulling back some of their expectations there.
Overall, I mean, the takeaway here, yes, the change in leadership to Democrats in control of Congress may limit some of the potential upside that we would’ve seen potentially over what our forecasts are right now. But honestly, I don’t think we foresee any major changes in the largest of the defense spending programs. Maybe it’s just me being cynical, but all politicians kind of like defense spending, especially when they can bring some of that spending to their own constituents. I don’t see any big cutbacks whatsoever in defense spending overall. For most long-term investors, I’d say these stocks are pretty attractive here. My pick is still L3Harris LHX. That’s the one that we’ve talked about, why we think it is probably one of the best-positioned defense stocks really, to be able to capitalize on how more modern warfare is evolving.
Hansen: Great. Yeah, we have mentioned L3Harris a few times. You can refer to past episodes for more information there. It sounds like defense stocks are kind of short-term volatility, but the long-term case has not changed.
Sekera: Exactly.
Stock Pick: GOOG/GOOGL
Hansen: Great. Moving on to your picks this week, you’ve brought us five stocks that look like buys after earnings, starting with Alphabet GOOG/GOOGL, which is an interesting choice given the market. First, let’s give us the overview.
Sekera: All right. Of course, Alphabet in and of itself is now a 5-star-rated stock—our highest rating—and trades at a 34% discount to fair value. Not a great dividend stock, only 0.30% dividend yield, but again, trading at a very large discount from fair value. We rate the company with a Medium Uncertainty and we assign it a wide economic moat. In fact, it’s one of the widest economic moats. It’s one of only two companies whose moat sources rely on four of the five moat sources.
Hansen: Now, Alphabet was at the center of the AI selloff a few weeks back. The stock tanked after a third-quarter earnings report that the market just did not like, but Morningstar went the other way, and we actually bumped our fair value estimate of that stock. Explain why our view is different from the market’s here.
Sekera: Yeah. Well, the market really crushed the stock because they ended up missing on both the top line and the bottom line as compared with the consensus estimates that are out there. But when you look at the numbers, we didn’t think that they were actually all that bad. I mean, revenue was up 25%, which, when you think about it, for a company as large as they are, generating a 25% increase in revenue is really just still astounding growth. Their operating margins expanded by 130 basis points. Google Cloud, in and of itself, grew over 100%. That part of their business now constitutes about a quarter of their total revenue. It was only 15% about a year ago, and there’s still a long runway of growth for that part of their business over the next couple of years.
The problem was the search business. Search came in at a 12% growth rate. The market was looking for at least a 17% growth rate, and I think that’s specifically what caused the stock to tank. It goes back to some of the concerns that we had with the stock, that the market had on this stock a couple of years ago, that artificial intelligence will end up eating away at their Search business over time. You can even see within their search business, like AI Overviews and AI Mode, is growing as a percentage of their total search queries. Now, from our point of view, we’re not that concerned about it because if there’s one thing that Google knows how to do is how to figure out how to be able to monetize its products and its data. Maybe they’re not generating as much revenue on AI usage now, but we think that over time they will be able to capture that value.
Now looking forward, we still expect Google Cloud to generate just crazy amounts of growth, especially because they’re now going to start selling their TPUs instead of just renting them out. That’s now a new revenue source. As you mentioned, we did raise our fair value to $450 a share from $433. It’s still one of those stocks where, when you look at our model, we have a five-year compound annual growth rate for earnings of 20%, yet it’s only trading at 17 times our 2027 earnings estimate. That estimate’s $17.27 per share. So, still a GARP stock, growth at a reasonable price.
Stock Pick: CCI
Hansen: Yeah. I want to pull out two key things that it seems to me on Alphabet, which is long runway for growth in the future, and also Google knows how to monetize, which is a thing we’ve mentioned before. Even as the dynamics of that pricing environment change, it seems like our analyst is confident they’ll find a way to make money.
OK, let’s move on to number two. We have Crown Castle CCI; that’s a REIT. We’ve talked about it before. Give us the key stats there.
Sekera: Crown Castle is a 4-star-rated stock, trades at a 20% discount as a REIT, and has a very nice, healthy dividend yield at 4.7%. We rate the company with a Medium Uncertainty. We assign it a narrow economic moat, with that moat being based on efficient scale and switching costs.
Hansen: Crown Castle came up when we talked about SpaceX a few weeks back and about SpaceX’s SPCX purchase of telecom infrastructure. Why do you like the stock?
Sekera: Well, I think there are really two reasons to own the stock. One, just fundamentally, in and of itself, we think that the stock is undervalued irrespective of whether or not SpaceX does or does not end up trying to get into the wireless business. Of course, if they do, they need to go to people like Crown Castle and then lease space on their tower. That would be a huge amount of upside that we don’t currently model in. But if we just look at the fundamentals of the business in and of itself, the company’s done a couple of things. They ended up getting rid of some of their prior businesses that were low margin, like their low-margin fiber business, their small cell business. That is going to end up allowing them to mix shift toward 100% of tower revenue, which is a higher operating margin than those other businesses.
We’re looking for some margin expansion that I think the market hasn’t necessarily priced in just yet. I think it’s a combination of one: You get the fundamentals of that mix shift, and then that will boost the price over time. And then two: If we’re wrong, and SpaceX does decide to build out their own wireless network, they’re going to need to place equipment on towers. They’re going to need to go to Crown Castle, and that’s going to be a whole new revenue stream that we haven’t incorporated into our fair value yet.
Stock Pick: CNH
Hansen: Great. So, two ways to win on that one, depending on how it all shakes out. All right. Number three is CNH Industrial CNH, which makes agricultural machinery. What’s the overview there?
Sekera: CNH is a 5-star-rated stock, trades at a 43% discount, and has a 0.8% dividend yield. We rate the company with a Medium Uncertainty and we assign a narrow economic moat based on switching costs and intangible assets.
Hansen: All right. And tell us why you like it.
Sekera: They recently announced a [joint venture]. Essentially, what they’re going to do with this JV is use it as a way to divest their construction machinery business. Now, when we’ve talked about this company in the past, I think it was like 80/20, like 80% of the business was based on agricultural machinery, 20% was being based on construction machinery. But the problem with their construction machinery is it was just too small to be able to compete effectively against the larger global competitors. We think that by essentially divesting out of this business, we’re going to get, now, a focused pure play on ag equipment. I think you’re going to get some good margin performance here going forward. I think the market is also very positive on this mixed shift change as well. The stock was up 10% after the announcement.
I think this is one where you’ve got some good positive momentum in how they’re changing the fundamentals of the business to be able to focus on what really is their core market, get away from some of that stuff that’s been pulling their margins down in the past. As they get the benefit from that, I think that’s something that will be a good tailwind for the stock.
Stock Pick: ET
Hansen: OK, fantastic. Number four, Energy Transfer ET. This is an oil and gas company. They reported their pretty solid second-quarter earnings earlier this month. Give us the highlights.
Sekera: Sure. Energy Transfer is a 4-star-rated stock, trades at a 22% discount, and has a 7.1% dividend yield. You have to remember, though, Energy Transfer is not like a normal stock. It’s actually what’s called a master limited partnership. You end up getting different tax treatment for this. This is one that, depending on what your tax situation is, you may want to try and figure out where and what type of account you would want to own it in if this is a stock you have an interest in. We assigned the company a Medium Uncertainty, but it is a no-economic-moat stock. We do not believe that this company has necessarily long-term or durable competitive advantages that will allow it to outearn its weighted average cost of capital over time. But we do think that it’s currently trading at a very large discount to its intrinsic valuation.
Hansen: OK. Now I imagine that is part of the investment case. What is the rest of the investment case?
Sekera: Yeah. Essentially what the company does is it transports, stores, processes, and exports oils and natural gas. It’s the one that actually owns the pipelines and all the infrastructure that connect, really, the energy producers to the users, to the utilities, to power plants, the refineries, and so forth. When we take a look at their results, I mean it’s kind of everything you’d want to have when you have an earnings release. It was better-than-expected results, increased guidance. We raised our fair value. From my point of view, everything’s looking to the upside here.
Stock Pick: PNR
Hansen: Fantastic. And that brings us to number five. We have Pentair PNR, which is a new pick. Never talked about it before. This is a water treatment company. I know its business is kind of three-pronged, including, I think, pools. Run us through the stats on Pentair.
Sekera: Pentair is a 4-star-rated stock. It’s a 25% discount from fair value; 1.6% dividend yield. We rate it with a Medium Uncertainty and assign it a narrow economic moat, that narrow moat being based on switching costs and intangible assets.
Hansen: Why is Pentair a buy right now?
Sekera: Yeah, I like it because, one, the stock surged 13% after earnings. The market definitely started understanding what our investment thesis is after that, but we still maintained our $91 fair value, and the stock’s still at a 25% discount. I like that upward momentum and we still have further to run in our view. Now, what happened with the stock is we think that the market overly punished them after, really, what was a disastrous second-quarter earnings report. I think this is really just kind of the market getting over that in the past and really now starting to look forward to what the company should be able to do over time.
As you mentioned, the company is a water technology play. They manufacture equipment and systems used to move, filter, treat, and manage water. Has three main segments. The largest is the water solutions business; that’s 39% of their revenue. That’s going to be your water filtration, purification, treatment, commercial ice machines, things like that. They have products that serve residential customers as well as restaurants, food and beverage companies, and so forth. The next largest portion is their pool business. That’s 37% of revenue. And then the last 24% of revenue is their flow business. So, think pumps, filtration systems, water transportation, wastewater, things like that. Going to be very much more industrial-type companies, utilities, and so forth.
Our five-year compound annual growth rate for earnings is 12.9%. Stock trades right at 13 times our 2027 earnings forecast. This is one where I kind of like that upward momentum. I like the discount. I like the business that they’re in. I don’t know. I think this is a good one for investors to take a look at for a certain part of their portfolio.
Hansen: Fantastic. Well, that is our last list. Thank you so much, Dave. You made it to the end. I prescribe chicken soup and a nap and maybe a sick day, but thank you so much for taking the time this morning to walk us through everything. Viewers and listeners who’d like more information about any of the stocks Dave talked about can visit morningstar.com for all the details, and Susan will be back next week. On my part, I would like to say a huge thank you to everyone for letting me sit in these past few weeks. It has been a blast. I’ve really enjoyed it.
Sekera: Well, and thank you, Sarah. No, we really appreciate you picking up the baton and running with it. You’ve done a great job.
Hansen: I’m no Susan.
Sekera: We really appreciate it. And when Susan is on vacation, we look forward to having you back.
Hansen: Oh, well, thank you so much. The next time she goes to the beach, I’ll be here. OK. We hope you’ll tune in next Monday morning to see Susan for The Morning Filter podcast. That’s at 9 a.m. Eastern, 8 a.m. Central. In the meantime, please like this episode and subscribe. I have no doubt we’ll have an exciting week ahead, so enjoy. Have a great week, everybody.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

