David Blanchett: Why the Years Before Retirement Can Be So Risky
The retirement researcher explains why market losses just before retirement can be especially damaging and how to approach portfolio risk as retirement nears.

Subscribe to Morningstar’s The Long View from your mobile device: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Our guest on the podcast today is David Blanchett. David is the head of retirement research for Prudential Financial and a portfolio manager for Prudential Global Investment Management. He’s also an adjunct professor of wealth management at The American College of Financial Services and a research fellow for the Alliance for Lifetime Income. Previously, he was head of retirement research at Morningstar Investment Management, LLC. David is a prolific writer and thinker about retirement-related issues. One of the big takeaways from our conversation is that, with so much uncertainty around lifetime spending, health shocks, and long-term-care expenses, it can be valuable to plan for multiple retirement scenarios rather than lock yourself into a single set of assumptions. As retirees move from adding money to their portfolios to taking it out, the process becomes deeply complicated and deeply personal. David helps us understand the different factors at play and the best practices for both individuals and the advisors helping them.
Episode Highlights
- Retirement Spending: Smile or Smirk?
- Rethinking Safe Withdrawal Rates
- Why Retirees Struggle to Spend
- The Behavioral Case for Lifetime Income
- TIPS Ladders, Target-Date Funds, and Tontines
- Rethinking the Retirement Risk Zone
- What Drives Retirement Satisfaction
- Redesigning Retirement Planning
Transcript
Amy Arnott: Hi, and welcome to The Long View. I’m Amy Arnott, portfolio strategist for Morningstar.
Ben Johnson: And I’m Ben Johnson, head of client solutions with Morningstar.
Arnott: Our guest on the podcast today is David Blanchett. David is the head of retirement research for Prudential Financial and a portfolio manager for Prudential Global Investment Management. He’s also an adjunct professor of wealth management at The American College of Financial Services and a research fellow for the Alliance for Lifetime Income. Previously, he was head of retirement research at Morningstar Investment Management, LLC.
David is such a prolific writer and thinker about so many different retirement-related issues. One of the big takeaways for me from our conversation today was, with so much uncertainty about lifetime spending and potential health shocks, potential expenses for long-term care, why it can be valuable as you’re doing a retirement plan to think of multiple scenarios. Instead of having one plan that you’re locked into with certain assumptions, you can test out different scenarios and make sure that your plan is able to sustain different types of events that might happen.
Johnson: Absolutely, Amy. I think what David outlined, just with respect to how advisors might be able to help their clients to navigate this new and critical part of their investment lifecycles whereby they’ve gone from adding dollars to their pile to taking them off amid all of those myriad uncertainties, it’s a deeply complicated and deeply personal situation. I think David really helped us to understand all of the different factors at play and what some of the best practices might be for both individuals and the advisors that are helping them.
Arnott: All right, so let’s take a listen. David, welcome to The Long View.
David Blanchett: Great to be here.
Retirement Spending: Smile or Smirk?
Arnott: Well, it’s great to have you here. We wanted to start out by talking a bit about retirement spending, which is an area that you have done a lot of research on. The retirement spending smile has become one of your best-known ideas, but you recently published a paper suggesting that smirk might actually be a better description for the typical retiree spending pattern. Maybe you could talk a little bit about what changed your thinking about that and what this newer data tell us that earlier research didn’t?
Blanchett: Sure. There’s a lot to possibly unpack there. If I go back over a decade to when I first wrote the paper, what caught my attention at the time was this idea of the go-go, the slow-go, and the no-go years. It’s kind of a well-known concept of how people transition their spending in retirement. I wanted to test it. There’s a dataset that is widely used in retirement research called the Health and Retirement Study. In it, I looked at how the same households changed their spending as they evolved through retirement.
What I found, effectively focusing on the average change—it was actually regression, but let’s not go there. Let’s just call it the average—what I found was that people didn’t increase their spending every year by inflation. A super common assumption in most retirement income planning tools is that you increase your spending every year by inflation. What I found was that when you first enter retirement, you might spend a little bit more than inflation. If inflation’s 3%, you’re spending 4% more, but that tended to go down as you transitioned into the slow-go years. You’re spending maybe one or two less in inflation. Then what I found, the smile is the real change in spending; it ticked back up later in retirement. One kind of nuance of the analysis that I was aware of that I didn’t fully elaborate in the paper is that it’s the average. A problem with averages is that outliers affect the average.
Other research had been done using the same exact dataset that talked about this constant real decline throughout retirement, more like a smirk. The idea of the new research was to reconcile this idea of how do you have different researchers using the same dataset that reach different conclusions? With the new analysis, it kind of suggests that they’re both there, where there are some households who have these significant end-of-life healthcare expenses that kind of have that average change go up. But for most households, that average change keeps going down. The idea is just thinking about the nuances between a smile and a smirk, as well as maybe how it could affect other countries, for example, that have different healthcare systems.
Johnson: David, I’m curious: When you think about that fairly steady decline, controlling maybe for some of these outliers, how much of that do you think is effectively discretionary versus nondiscretionary? Just sort of naturally, like I’m becoming less mobile, I’m less interested in traveling the world versus, gosh, I’m really worried about next year and the year following and a whole host of other things, and I’m going to rein in that spending on my own after I have my initial “woo-hoo, I’m retired” spring break, as it were.
Blanchett: That’s the first question I usually get because there’s a lot of narrative out there that America has this retirement crisis. I disagree with that notion. But even if you control for households who have tons of money, who could spend more, they tend to spend less. I think there is a decent share of households out there that really are constrained, and they have to cut back on it because they’re just not in good financial shape. But if you just isolate those that have lots of money, or I guess more wealth than their spending would imply, they cut back as well. It’s both, but the effect persists even among wealthier households that could spend more, which to me just suggests it’s this very real thing that happens as we move through retirement. But I mean, I guess an important point is the effect is very messy.
So, this is the average trend. Some households, they just spend tons more over time; some spend tons less. The goal, at least for me in the research, is to give a better guideline for how you might talk to clients about what the average expectation should be.
Arnott: For those retirees who do have more of a smile pattern where spending is increasing later in life, what have you found in terms of, do they have common characteristics? Do they tend to be lower wealth, higher wealth levels, or does a lot of it just depend on specific health situations?
Blanchett: What really it tends to be is it tends to be some kind of health shock later in retirement. I’m sure, as we all know, the implications of a health shock increase the longer that you live. The older you are, the more expensive health shocks tend to become, long-term care, things like that. That’s been kind of the primary thing. Again, the effect is pretty messy. It’s definitely there, but predominantly healthcare is the thing that kind of drives this kind of end-of-life increase in spending.
Rethinking Safe Withdrawal Rates
Johnson: I’m curious, based on some of the patterns that you’ve sussed out here and you’re describing, and I think in particular, just this steady decline in real spending, what’s ultimately the impact on sustainable initial spending rates? Does that mean maybe some of what we know or what we think we know about safe withdrawal rates and the analysis that we use to derive them has just always been way too conservative?
Blanchett: I think that’s the key. It’s just that when we think about withdrawal rates, really all you’re giving someone is guidance on what they should do today, assuming a set of assumptions would happen in the future. I think that if you think about where people talk about safe withdrawal rates for retirees, it’s usually between 4%-5%. But if you say, “Hey, there’s a really good chance that you’re going to reduce your spending throughout retirement,” that can move to 5%-7%. I think for me, the key is giving someone that kind of freedom to spend earlier in retirement if you incorporate this into a financial plan.
Arnott: With the impact of a healthcare shock and the potential impact that can have on spending later in life, what do you think is the best way for advisors to work with their clients to plan for that? Obviously there’s long-term-care insurance, which has its pros and cons, but do you advocate carving out a separate bucket of assets set aside for potential long-term care or other medical needs?
Blanchett: Yeah, I don’t have an especially good answer for long-term care. It’s the one thing I think that we don’t have a great solution for. If you’re really worried about living a long time, you can delay claiming Social Security; you can buy a lifetime income annuity. You mentioned long-term care; that’s a great option in theory. I know a lot of retirees who couldn’t get it because they’re not especially healthy. I don’t know that I have one great solution for that. You can carve out assets, but that’s kind of inefficient because most Americans don’t actually experience these significant healthcare shocks. I think that’s an area where a better public solution would be really beneficial.
Why Retirees Struggle to Spend
Johnson: One of your recent papers, David, shows that—and certainly we’ve heard more than enough anecdotal evidence to support this—that your retirees are really reluctant to draw on their investment portfolios as they begin to spend through retirement, even when they can afford to do so. What do you think explains that reluctance?
Blanchett: I think there are a lot of psychological barriers to spending that I don’t address in my research. I’ve been doing research on safe initial withdrawal rates for two decades, and it kind of assumes that people are these perfectly rational humans. They’re just going to take this money out no matter what. But if you look at it, people will spend lifetime income. They are very good at spending lifetime income. They’re pretty terrible at spending, like anything else—qualified savings, nonqualified savings, wage income, capital income—because I think that we train ourselves to live off a paycheck for 30 or 40 years. And so you become an ant, you become good at saving money, and you fixate on this balance every quarter, every year for however long. The notion of pulling money from it when you retire, given uncertain longevity, uncertain inflation, uncertain margins—all these uncertainties—it becomes really hard.
I think what happens for a lot of retirees is they underspend and then they kind of become used to underspending. I think that’s fine for a lot of folks, but if you saved money to really enjoy your retirement and then you don’t enjoy your retirement, that’s not the best way to plan for things. I think that what you’re referring to is kind of this idea of how do you structure retirement and compliance to kind of maximize the behavioral benefits? Increasingly, I don’t believe that people are well designed to pull money from portfolios, and so that’s where maybe alternative solutions that automate that would be really beneficial.
Johnson: Is it something potentially, I think of all the success we’ve seen in the accumulation phase of an investor’s lifecycle and really just all of the various behavioral nudges that have improved outcomes on the way up. Are there inverse solutions, similar to, every two weeks I’m going to put this amount of my paycheck pretax, that just kind of invert the solutions that we have for retirement savers?
Blanchett: Yeah. The overwhelming withdrawal strategy for most retirees is RMDs because we force them on people. I mean, technically people get all angry about [required minimum distributions], but you don’t have to spend it. It’s like a two-part step to actually spending your qualified savings. Part one is you have to take it out of the account, and then part two is you have to spend it. I think what RMDs do, though, is force someone to move that money from that qualified account into a taxable account where it can more easily be spent. I think that, to the extent that we wanted to, the easiest way to get retirees to spend more would be to have RMDs kick in at 65 and be even more aggressive in terms of the withdrawal rates because then you would be forcing them to take money out of the accounts.
What they do with it’s up to them, but right now the mechanism—you don’t have to touch it until you’re 73, going to 75—that creates a friction that I think reduces utilization of the savings.
Arnott: For advisors working with clients who have accumulated significant wealth but might be reluctant to spend it, have you found any practical interventions that seem to be effective in getting people more comfortable with spending more?
Blanchett: Given all of the uncertainties that exist with healthcare and the nuances around this kind of key assumption in a plan, I’m still kind of OK with running a financial plan where you do assume that spending increases every year by inflation. What you’re kind of doing there is building this kind of implicit healthcare bucket that they can use later in retirement. I think where this could be really beneficial for advisors, especially, is that they can kind of walk this concept through with clients by running like a second plan and saying, “Hey, in this primary plan, we’re going to assume that your spending increases by inflation. Maybe you can only spend $50,000 a year, but we’re going to run a second plan, and we’re going to show you this assumption where your spending declines by 2% a year or some other number, and in that plan you can spend 20% or 30% more today.” I think the idea is demonstrating that there’s a lot of kind of realities we get wrong. People tend to retire two to three years early. We don’t do a very good job estimating longevity. I think that, to the extent an advisor can walk someone through this analysis and this research, my key hope is it allows that individual to spend more earlier in retirement.
The Behavioral Case for Lifetime Income
Johnson: Related to what we were discussing previously, David, just around this almost mental differentiation, this separation between W-2 income, drawing from investment wealth as sort of a replacement for W-2 income, does that, I think, further support the case for some form or another of annuitization, even assuming that an investor is otherwise comfortable saying, “I’m going to liquidate X percent of my portfolio a year to fund my spending through retirement.”
Blanchett: It does. Annuitization is kind of a loaded term, right? The vast majority of lifetime income annuities don’t require annuitization, and I’ll define some terms. Most people don’t like giving their money irrevocably to an insurance company. Those products are like single-premium immediate annuities. Those are called SPIAs. There are deferred-income annuities; those are called DIAs. In the qualified space, if you meet a certain provision, you can have what’s called a qualifying longevity annuity contract, or QLAC. Those are typically products, and it varies by insurer. Some offer this thing called commutation, where you give the money away forever. The 80% or so of annuities that have lifetime income are actually living benefit structures where you still have access to the money. There’s kind of this optionality.
But that being said, I really think that I’ve looked at the potential benefits of lifetime income for two decades. In the past, I was mostly focused on the economic benefits. There’s like 50-plus years of research talking about how pooling mortality results in a better outcome on average than you having a plan to live to age 100, whatever else it is. But to me, it’s increasingly this idea of the behavioral benefits that I’m attracted to, where it’s just an easy button on retirement. Humans are not designed to make all these complex decisions, and advisors will say, “Hey, this is where I can help my clients.” I always say, “Well, I love me a good portfolio, but you can’t solve retirement with an efficient portfolio. As good as your portfolio is, it doesn’t provide certainty around longevity, around the markets.” That’s where my general rule of thumb is: I think that pretty much every American should have all their essential expenses covered with lifetime income.
When I talk about this, advisors will raise their hand and say, “David, I’ve got clients that have like $10 million; they’re never going to go broke.” And what I say is, well, then they need it for a different reason. Why they need it is because the fact that they have $10 million suggests they’re not kind of unlocking their savings. Why they might benefit from lifetime income or allocating to an annuity or something else, or delaying claiming Social Security, is because once you know you have your essential expenses covered, or maybe even all your expenses, it’s going to change how you perceive using the rest of your wealth. I think that a lot of advisors focus too much on the more, kind of, economic benefits, and they run a Monte Carlo simulation and they say it doesn’t make sense. I view the benefits more from that behavioral lens: It makes it easier to enjoy what you’ve saved in retirement.
Johnson: Is it almost like I think of it in terms of almost giving them permission to spend? This is an amount of money that you don’t have to worry about. You have permission to spend this amount as you see fit.
Blanchett: Yes. And there are other ways I think that we could do that. I think that you could get part of the way there if we did advanced RMDs at age 65. But the problem is people really don’t like depleting a portfolio given uncertain longevity. I think that lifetime income really is the one thing that—this is research I’ve done with Michael Finke; we have five papers on this now—that is clearly the most effective resource that retirees use in retirement.
Arnott: You’ve also argued that lifetime income should be viewed as a portfolio allocation decision instead of just an insurance purchase. How should investors think about how much to allocate to lifetime income as well as how that should impact the asset allocation for the rest of the portfolio?
Blanchett: Sure. A lot of advisors will build net worth statements for their clients, and I’ve been fighting a losing battle for at least a decade where I believe that the net present value of all lifetime income should be included in that balance sheet. For most Americans, especially those who work with financial advisors, the net present value of Social Security benefits is probably well over a million dollars. That is a $1 million government inflation-linked bond. That, if viewed in that context, could have important implications about how you build a portfolio. I think that there are other implications around the role of lifetime income when it comes to building portfolios. You should view lifetime income as a bondlike asset. This is somewhat nuanced, but even if the underlying portfolio is aggressive, when you overlay lifetime income, it decreases the effect of risk. I think too often we kind of focus on the assets, and we know that assets can create income. We don’t view those income-producing assets as assets on the balance sheet. When you do, it can radically change this definition of the efficient portfolio.
Johnson: David, you mentioned some of the different options, right? There’s a veritable alphabet soup of options on the annuity menu. How do you suggest that advisors, and ultimately the clients that they’re serving, approach doing due diligence on this product set, just given all the myriad factors that are in play?
Blanchett: Yeah. I do all this research sometimes, contrasting the efficacy of different products. What I say is what matters a lot more is finding a product or a solution that works well in how you think about planning for retirement than totally dismissing annuities. How the products work can be very, very different, like a QLAC versus a GLWB. They have radically different implications for how you design a retirement plan. I don’t really have a strong preference right now, like what product you use so much as how are you actively thinking about lifetime income products when you do a retirement income plan? For a lot of advisors out there, they don’t even think of annuities at all as a category to help someone figure out retirement. For me, it’s less about what is the best product versus do you understand the products and you understand where they might fit in terms of how you create plans for clients?
TIPS Ladders, Target-Date Funds, and Tontines
Arnott: We’ve heard a lot of enthusiasm about TIPS, Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, and TIPS ladders recently. As we’re taping this toward the beginning of September, real yields are higher than they’ve been since 2008. What do you think about a TIPS ladder as an alternative to an annuity, especially given the fact that you’re kind of building in that inflation protection?
Blanchett: So, a huge fan, especially today. Obviously rates can change between now and then, but I think one thing that people might not realize is that you cannot buy a lifetime income annuity that has an explicit link to inflation. None exist. There are some that kind of have, I would say, a soft link up until a certain cap, but there aren’t any that exist. If you want guaranteed income for life linked to inflation, Social Security is the only game in town. To me, though, that’s where TIPS can be great in terms of what they provide; you could call it a risk-free rate of return that is linked to inflation. That is incredibly valuable. I think that TIPS are fantastic. The only thing that worries me, though, is that they aren’t guaranteed for life. They’re going to be guaranteed for a certain term. I think that they can be an incredibly effective way to provide kind of an overlay or guarantee, but it just doesn’t have that lifetime income component.
Johnson: We touched briefly on some of the innovations we’ve seen that have helped investors get to the top of the hill, as it were, through the accumulation stage of their lifecycle. What we’ve seen now is that the next iteration of one of those solutions, one of those product sets, and target-date funds in particular, is simply attaching an annuity to the product. I’m curious to get your thoughts on that evolution and whether or not that can have a sort of meaningful impact on some of the problems that we’re discussing.
Blanchett: It’s like, yes and no. That’s a very complicated arena. I think that I’m very much for more Americans getting lifetime income, or I get, worried isn’t the right word, but people don’t know what’s in their target-date fund. You can include a product or a solution as part of the default investment, and most people will allocate to it, but will they actually end up utilizing that lifetime income benefit? I have this kind of framework: There are three steps required to getting higher utilization of lifetime income annuities in [defined-contribution] plans. The first is to make plan sponsors OK with including it. We’ve done a lot there with fiduciary safe harbors, things like that. The second step is getting participants to allocate to it, and you can do that in a target-date fund. The third step, though, I think is probably the hardest, and that’s getting participants to actually activate the income benefit. I think that’s where we’ve seen problems today.
What I like, regardless, though, is just this increased focus on the lifetime income annuities across the industry. To me, it’s neat to see the solutions that are evolving, where even if participants may not end up utilizing that product in the DC construct, maybe they’re curious, and when they roll out of the plan when they turn 65, whatever, they talk to their advisor about it. And so to me, what I like is the high-level focus on lifetime income. Whether or not we can solve a lot of this in the DC space, I think remains to be seen based upon participant utilization.
Johnson: Could the solution just simply be another nudge, automated sort of the inverse of auto-enrollment?
Blanchett: You may see some research coming out from us soon talking about the idea of automatic lifetime income. Again, I think, when we’ve done surveys on this, and just to be clear, we would never recommend something where it’s irrevocable, where someone’s money is automatically annuitized without any kind of provision to get it back at a certain age. But right now you have to opt in to the lifetime income benefit. What if it were the reverse? What if when you were completing the enrollment form, whatever else it is, it would say, “Hey, we’re going to assume at age 65 you will start receiving benefits.” I think that would have a meaningful increase in participants who receive the lifetime annuity. I think it actually makes people happier. I think if you see surveys on those that have bought lifetime annuities, they tend to be happy they made a decision. The problem is getting them to pull the trigger. To your point, the more we can make it automatic, the easier it’s going to be to kind of reduce those friction points toward utilization.
Arnott: Well, and part of it might also be education, with plan sponsors trying to educate their employees, maybe starting when people are 55 and just helping them understand what their options are at retirement and trying to have an ongoing conversation and educational effort about that prior to retirement.
Blanchett: Yeah. I mean, I think education can do a lot. I think people’s interest in consuming that and acting upon it just varies dramatically. I think advisors are critical. I think advice just is, people, I think, benefit from advice about the lifecycle, but around retirement is where having access to an advisor or even maybe robo-tools or advice can really help someone make the best choices possible. I think yes, the more we can do to educate people, the better, but retirement’s really, really, really complicated. It’s kind of hard to get people kind of up to speed where they probably would need to be to make these decisions on their own without some kind of help.
Arnott: You’ve also done some research on new structures like protected modern tontines. What problem are tontines solving that conventional annuities don’t solve particularly well?
Blanchett: Sure. There are lots of different ways that you can create mortality pooled structures. In the US, 99.99% of the assets are in solutions that are offered by insurance companies that have an explicit guarantee. Another way to structure it is via what’s called a tontine. There’s a modern tontine; there are lots of words we can use to describe these, but effectively what they are is that a group of individuals get together, and the payouts you receive depend upon the mortality experience of that pool.
A benefit there is that the payouts can be higher because there’s no kind of insurance company charging its fee to administer and guarantee the payouts. The con, though, is that if that group lives a really long time, your payouts could be lower. We’ve seen structures introduced in the US and in Canada. There’s a lot going on that’s very similar in the UK and Australia. I do think we’re going to see a lot of innovation in this space because the benefits of lifetime income are pretty powerful. I do believe that having some guarantees is probably really important out of the gate, especially in the US given the current market environment. But the idea of more structures to create protected lifetime income, I think, is great for retirees.
Arnott: Yeah. One of the classic problems with tontines is if you’re in a pool with a group of other people and you get more money if someone else dies, obviously that could create bad incentives or possible murder plots. I guess there are ways to work around that, though.
Blanchett: There are. I mean, I think the key is ensuring a large enough pool. Realistically, you want thousands and thousands of people, but I think that’s something that has existed in kind of fictional shows, and there have been books written about that. But I think for the most part, what’s interesting is I think this acknowledgment that we have this kind of decumulation puzzle and longevity-linked solutions are a way to solve that. I think we’ve done a really good job innovating in the guaranteed space. That, to me, is an area that is probably ripe for innovation.
Johnson: We’re talking about a puzzle here, to borrow your words, David, that is just so complex and so deeply personal. All these myriad assumptions ranging from longevity to spending preferences and habits—you name it. I’m curious: Is part of the solve, in addition to the help you emphasized of a professional, an advisor, some form or another of tool that can take these variables into account and at least spit out a nicely bounded range of possible solutions, spending and sort of liquidation patterns, you name it. What are you seeing in that space? Is there anything that you found especially helpful as almost a calculator to try to solve some of these problems?
Blanchett: Yeah. I mean, I think that most advisors are using some type of calculator to figure out what their clients should spend. I could spend a lot of time talking about where I think the calculators don’t use the best assumptions. But I think the key behind the calculators and the advisors is giving clients some level of assurance. If you don’t have access to an advisor, if you don’t use the calculators, you don’t have any idea what you can do. Yes, I love to get into the weeds and talk about the nuances of what you should do for your longevity assumptions and how you model returns and how we incorporate dynamic withdrawals and all these different things. But I think the key is having a plan because the plan gives you peace of mind about what is a reasonable thing to do today.
I think that what’s really hard is that if you think about retirement, it could last 30 or 40 years. Realistically, what you’re telling someone is, as of today, time zero, what they can be doing, and that’s where they’re so valuable. I think that the key is planning to give someone that confidence they can actually enjoy their retirement, because in the absence of that, people just tend to spend very little.
Rethinking the Retirement Risk Zone
Arnott: We also wanted to spend some time talking about the retirement risk zone. I think the conventional wisdom is that the five-year window after retirement is the riskiest period, but you’ve actually found that returns immediately before retirement can matter more than returns after you retire. Can you explain why you found that pattern?
Blanchett: Sure. That was a piece I did with Wade Pfau and Michael Finke looking at the idea of sequence risk. There are lots of ways that you can think about how the returns on a portfolio affect the outcome. I think that a lot of advisors think that sequence risk is the greatest when you first retire. But realistically, sequence risk is the greatest when your balance is the largest and the balance is the largest just before you retire and the years before that. I think that one thing that is just really important is not to be overly aggressive as you’re entering retirement. You can always risk-on in retirement should you choose to do so, but I just wouldn’t want someone to think, “Oh, sequence risk is really only a big deal when I first retire. I’m going to take on too much risk three years before retirement and then have this kind of really big market event.” The idea is just that the impact of bad returns varies over time, but it really is the most consequential, really, like the three years leading up to your retirement.
Johnson: What does that mean, David, just with respect to traditional rules of thumb around derisking portfolios as that moment approaches? I mean, if anything, I’m thinking of a glide path in almost a moment where you come from 30,000 feet down to 10,000 feet and then turn the nose back up. How does that cause us to maybe potentially rethink just traditional notions of how we dial up or down our portfolio risk, our financial risk as we come near to retirement?
Blanchett: Yeah. I think what you said is pretty spot-on. I mean, if you’re at 30,000 feet, you come to 10,000 feet, and maybe you could go back up, or you land a plane. I think the key is I’m not suggesting by any means that you move all into cash and you go crazy conservative because that’s risky too. I think the key is getting through early retirement and seeing how your, I mean, just use the word, luck has treated you. If you look back in time, certain retirees have been fantastically lucky. They’ve experienced market returns that were just explosive, fantastic for the first 10 or 15 years. Others have had the exact opposite.
And the thing is, that’s out of your hands. You don’t know what’s going to happen there. If you’re lucky, then you can possibly risk-on, risk-on. If you’re unlucky and you’ve got to make hard choices, do that. For me, the key there is not being overly conservative or aggressive as you move into retirement. It’s probably being maybe a little bit conservative and then reevaluating as your situation evolves.
Arnott: What about the decision of when to retire? I think right now we’ve had this fantastic bull market that’s been almost uninterrupted for such a long time. We have record numbers of 401(k) millionaires. I have to imagine there are a lot of people out there who are looking at their balances and saying, “I hit my number, I’m going to retire.” But is this potentially a riskier time because of reversion to the mean? The bull market is not going to last forever.
Blanchett: So, I want it to last forever before I caveat what I’m going to say.
Arnott: We do too.
Blanchett: I think if the markets could go up 15% a year every year for the next 50 years, that would be absolutely fantastic. But I guess for anyone who studied history, that hasn’t been the case. I mean, we’ve had an exceptional period of just phenomenal performance. If history is a guide, it is increasingly unlikely to continue. I think there’s a really unique question people have to ask themselves: If the market’s correct and they go down 30% or 40%—I’m just picking a number—how does that affect your retirement? This is not a suggestion to be tactical, but this is a different environment in that you can invest in fixed income today and achieve an incredibly attractive return versus maybe historical long-term averages. If you’re at the point of retirement and you can retire, how are you thinking about investing your portfolio?
I don’t want you to go crazy, crazy conservative, but if you keep risking on, if you’re all in equities, you’re all in large caps, whatever else it is, what would the implications of that be? I think what we often forget is these unique correlations between the odds of you getting laid off, for example, and your portfolio, where if you’re two or three years from retirement, you’re thinking, “Man, if I just stay crazy aggressive for the next two or three years, I’m going to be golden.” Well, if next week the market drops dramatically, the odds of you getting let go at your job increase dramatically too. I think I wouldn’t want someone to think that, oh, I’m going to keep being aggressive because the markets have done so well. To your point, it might be time to take risk off the table if a correction really would affect you, especially if you don’t have the capacity to rally from that. If you’re younger, it’s like, OK. If you’re 45 years old, the markets crash, you’ve still got 20 years to work. If you’re 63 years old and at the tail end of your career, you don’t really have time for that bad luck to correct itself.
What Drives Retirement Satisfaction
Johnson: David, some of the recent research you’ve done begins to move beyond just the most immediately measurable versions of wealth and expands that definition a bit, looking beyond just sheer financial wealth. I’m curious, among your findings, what surprised you most about the relationship between that actual measurable wealth? I’ve finished with $10 million, I’ve reached retirement, and how satisfied those retirees actually are or are not?
Blanchett: Sure. At a high level, most Americans are very satisfied in retirement. The Health and Retirement Study asked this question: Overall, how would you say you’re satisfied with retirement? And the answers are like: very moderately [satisfied], not at all. About half of Americans are very satisfied with retirement. Collectively, we’re actually doing fantastic. You have about 85%-90% either moderately or very satisfied. Collectively, a really happy group. I focus a lot on the financial aspects of retirement. Things like what is your overall level of savings, and how much income do you have that’s guaranteed for life? Those are also both positively correlated with well-being. The more wealth you have, the happier you are, and the more lifetime income you have, the happier you are.
If you look at other factors like social connectivity and health, those are probably even more important in terms of the spectrum of happiness as you move across different levels. I think that this is kind of somewhat out of my domain of expertise, but if you get to retirement with lots of money and lots of lifetime income, but no friends and you’re in poor health, you’re going to be pretty miserable. And that’s obvious, but that’s not the kind of thing that I am talking about. I don’t know how often advisors talk about it, but I think to me the key here is if you look at what is related to retirement satisfaction, there’s a lot more than just the financial stuff, and that’s obvious. But to me, what was surprising in this research—it focuses on this idea of wealth and well-being—is just how much more important that other stuff, and again, that was health and social connectivity, was in terms of defining how happy someone is, especially in retirement.
Arnott: Also along the lines of nonfinancial factors in retirement, you recently wrote a piece for Kiplinger titled “Dog People vs. Cat People: Who Has a Better Retirement?” What did you find there, and do you think there are any other factors that might be contributing to differences between the two?
Blanchett: If we’re honest, that was a little bit for fun. As background, my wife is a veterinarian. We have three dogs, two guinea pigs, and a tortoise. We’re big in the pet game. And every year Prudential does what’s called a Pulse Survey. We included a few questions in the Pulse Survey asking individuals: Do you own pets? If so, do you own cats, dogs, cats and dogs, or something else? I was really curious, OK, how does pet ownership change over time of any kind of relationships between life outcomes and pet ownerships? One high-level finding was that pet ownership really does decline pretty significantly at older ages. I think that’s somewhat intuitive. I think that—I didn’t want the tortoise, being honest with you; my son wanted the tortoise—and so I think a lot of times we have pets because our kids want them. But as we get older, though, there’s a strong relationship between whether you have a pet today and whether you have one when you’re retired.
Next, I looked at things like how life outlook has changed across different types of pets. The differences weren’t technically statistically significant, but there were differences in that individuals who own dogs had better life outlooks than those who own cats. If you own a cat and a dog, you were technically fine because you’re also a dog owner, but there was this difference in how people perceive their retirement changing. Part of that could just be because people who own cats are different from those who own dogs. But as someone who is on Team Dog, I was delighted to see that Team Dog folks tend to be a bit happier than the Team Cat folks.
Arnott: Well, and of course, if you own a dog, you have to take your dog for walks. You’re getting exercise, you’re going out and meeting people.
Blanchett: I think that’s actually a huge part of it is that you could just let them outside technically too, but it’s a more social creature that requires you to engage more in retirement. The earlier thing we talked about with wealth and well-being, so I was thinking about what are the things that old Americans should do? Pickleball is a really good example of an activity that addresses both physical health and social connectivity. Having a dog, to some extent, also kind of addresses both if you take them on walks. But I think the key is, as we get older, doing things that make us be active and make us see other people, just because it really does appear to drive retirement satisfaction.
Johnson: We’ve got two dogs in our house, David, so I’m just going to put a stamp of statistical significance on your findings.
Blanchett: All right. I love it.
Johnson: Extra side of a confirmation bias on my part. I’m curious, when you describe some of these defining sort of wealth more broadly concepts, how do you think about advisors’ role in engaging with clients in things that aren’t showing up on a quarterly statement or in a spreadsheet? Have you seen any advisors expand into these corners, things that they might be doing successfully or less so?
Blanchett: I mean, I’d like to think so. I think that a lot of advisors might view their role as wealth maximizers. It’s my job to build a really efficient portfolio and pick these fantastic investments, and that will allow my client to achieve their goals and objectives. And I wouldn’t say that’s wrong, but that’s not the whole story. It’s this idea that your client can have a gigantic portfolio, but if they’re not spending money on things they would enjoy because they’re fixated on that portfolio, then you’re not helping your client achieve the best possible retirement. I think that it does require maybe a different type of conversation than this pure investment-focused outcomes analysis. Because if your client gets to retirement and gets through retirement and you just grow the portfolio and they don’t enjoy it, that to me isn’t the optimal outcome. I do think more advisors are kind of hyperaware of this, but this isn’t my domain of expertise.
I don’t know how to have the conversations with people about the importance of health and the importance of social connectivity. But one of the things that another researcher found recently is that there’s a positive correlation between how long you live and having lifetime income. I think the first thing you have to acknowledge is that people who are healthier are much more likely to buy or allocate to lifetime income. There’s endogeneity, of course; people who have lifetime income, by definition, tend to be healthier than the average American. Let’s just assume we can control for that. I think there’s this spillover effect there where if you have it and you have money, you can spend money on things that you enjoy. You will go on vacations; you will do things with it that do have positive longevity outcomes. And you’re not going to see that in a mean-variance optimization. There are things that kind of exist beyond how we think about investments improving outcomes that really can matter for retirement that I think advisors should hopefully just think more about when it comes to creating these plans for the clients.
Johnson: You can feel confident when you go to buy that new golden doodle.
Blanchett: Or whatever it is. Again, tongue-in-cheek, I mentioned pickleball, but I think that’s a great example. To the extent that you allow yourself to enjoy that—I don’t know, go on trips or do things—that can have a meaningful impact on retirement satisfaction. There’s this question like, do you think you can afford to do it? If you convince yourself that you can’t afford to take these vacations, do these things you love, I think they can have really important negative long-term implications on your retirement satisfaction.
Redesigning Retirement Planning
Arnott: Before we wrap up, I wanted to ask: If you could kind of redesign the standard retirement planning process from scratch based on what you’ve learned in your research, what are the main assumptions you would change first?
Blanchett: So, people kind of talk longingly about defined-benefit plans. And you could argue—
Arnott: Like the halcyon days of when people had pensions.
Blanchett: I mean, the good old days. We still have Social Security. And I do not think defined-benefit plans really make a ton of sense for most companies today. You build widgets. Why do you want to have to hire someone who is 45, and they work for you for 10 years, and then in 10 years you’ve got to start … It doesn’t make sense for companies to be doing this, but that’s where insurance companies or other pooled products exist. I think the defined-contribution space is very much here to stay, but I really do wish there was this bigger focus on just converting savings to lifetime income when you retire because it just radically simplifies everything. We’ve created a situation. We’ve got a hundred million-ish households at some point who have to figure this out on their own and the evidence from other countries on their own to suggest that we’re not good at that. I think the more that, I don’t want to use this word, mandates, but the more that we can kind of refocus everyone on doing that, I think the better retirement would be holistically.
Arnott: Well, thank you so much for joining us, David. It’s been great talking with you.
Blanchett: Sure thing.
Arnott: Thank you for joining us on The Long View. If you could, please take a moment to subscribe to and rate the podcast on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. You can follow me on social media at Amy Arnott on LinkedIn.
Johnson: And at Ben Johnson, CFA on LinkedIn or @MstarBenJohnson on X.
Arnott: George Castady is our engineer for the podcast, Jessica Bebel produces the show notes each week, and Jennifer Gierat copy edits our transcripts. Finally, we’d love to get your feedback. If you have a comment or a guest idea, please email us at thelongview@morningstar.com. Until next time, thanks for joining us.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

