5 Stocks With Moat Rating Changes This Month

Palantir and Cheesecake Factory saw moat upgrades, while Tradeweb was downgraded.

Logo and signage of Palantir on building headquarters.
Smith Collection/Gado via Getty
Securities in This Article
MarketAxess Holdings Inc
(MKTX)
Tradeweb Markets Inc Class A
(TW)
The Cheesecake Factory Inc
(CAKE)
Palantir Technologies Inc Ordinary Shares - Class A
(PLTR)
Fair Isaac Corp
(FICO)

Economic moat ratings, which reflect a company’s durable competitive advantages, are at the heart of Morningstar’s stock-picking methodology. Companies with competitive advantages that are seen as lasting at least 20 years are assigned wide moats. Those seen as able to fend off competition for 10–20 years receive narrow moats. Companies that analysts do not believe possess significant competitive advantages are not assigned moats. When combined with low valuations, stocks with moats have historically had a greater chance of outperforming over the long term.

With moats’ multi-decade focus, these ratings are not often reassigned. But changes within a company or its competitive landscape can lead Morningstar’s equity analysts to adjust ratings. According to Allen Good, who heads Morningstar’s moat rating committee, “We take a long-term perspective when assigning moat ratings, so they are unlikely to change frequently. News events may create volatility in share prices, but that does not mean a company’s competitive position has changed meaningfully. However, analysts are continually testing their assumptions and evaluating a company’s advantages. When an analyst determines something fundamental has changed to impact a company’s longer-term outlook, a moat rating change may be necessary.”

Once a month, we screen US-listed stocks covered by Morningstar analysts for any changes in moat ratings. Since Oct. 13, of the 883 stocks on the list, five companies saw changes in their moat ratings. Two stocks were upgraded, and three were downgraded.

Economic Moat Ratings Across Morningstar’s US Coverage

Following this month’s changes, of the 883 US-listed stocks covered by Morningstar, 213 have wide moats, 370 have narrow moats, and 300 have no moat. 34% have no moat, 42% have narrow moats, and 24% have wide moats.

How Economic Moat Ratings Work

Morningstar’s economic moat rating is a key element in evaluating a company’s long-term competitive advantage and its ability to generate excess returns on capital over many years. Morningstar equity analysts determine a company’s economic moat by examining how well it can maintain or grow its market position. A moat helps protect a company’s profits from rivals. Some businesses are better equipped to preserve these advantages over time, while others operate in more competitive or vulnerable industries.

A company with a strong and enduring competitive advantage can often command better pricing, retain loyal customers, and operate more efficiently. These qualities support long-term value creation, which is especially important when evaluating a stock’s potential for superior long-term returns.

Morningstar identifies five primary sources that contribute to a company’s economic moat:

  • Switching Costs: Barriers that discourage customers from changing providers due to time, expense, or inconvenience.
  • Network Effects: The increasing value of a product or service as more people use it, reinforcing its dominance.
  • Intangible Assets: Patents, regulatory licenses, and brand recognition that give a company a distinct edge.
  • Cost Advantage: The ability to deliver goods or services at a lower cost than competitors, leading to greater margins or price competitiveness.
  • Efficient Scale: Operating in markets with limited competition due to natural or structural constraints.

Here’s a closer look at the stocks with moat rating changes this month, along with our analysts’ commentary.

Palantir PLTR

  • Morningstar Rating: ★★★
  • Sector: Technology
  • Industry: Software - Infrastructure

We assign Palantir a wide moat rating based on switching costs and intangible assets. Palantir’s competitive advantage lies in owning the applications, workflows, and automations that accumulate around its platforms. Palantir’s deep entrenchment in its customers’ operations and the high return on investment on its solutions, position the firm well to remain a leading software vendor and earn excess returns on invested capital over the next two decades.

We believe switching costs play a key role in Palantir’s wide moat, driven by the mission-criticality of its solutions, the significant time and monetary investments required to maintain them, and the high cost of failure risked by switching. Palantir turns fragmented data silos and business logic into a centralized, living system that supports decision-making and execution. Its software ingests data of all forms to create an ontology, a digital model mapping each object, action, and relationship in the customer’s operations to create a shared, structured view of itself. The ontology both reads and writes decisions back to the systems where the work happens, creating a real-time, comprehensive system of action that improves over time.

Jivyaa Vaidya, Morningstar analyst

Tradeweb Markets TW

  • Morningstar Rating: ★★★
  • Sector: Financial Services
  • Industry: Capital Markets

In our view, Tradeweb has achieved a narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating as a result of its position as a leading platform for the electronic trading of a wide variety of fixed-income securities. Tradeweb serves the interdealer, institutional, and retail fixed-income markets through multiple trading protocols, each designed to meet different market needs, giving it a broader scope than its competitors. Fixed-income markets globally have been trending toward increased electronic trading, providing the company with substantial revenue growth, as the implicit and explicit cost reductions offered through its trading protocols pull more trading volume to its platform. This tailwind along with the company’s existing network and liquidity pools has provided it with impressive returns on invested capital, expanding margins and a long road map for future growth, as many of the fixed-income products that trade on its platform are still primarily voice-traded. As Tradeweb’s trading volume increases, the additional revenue comes with a higher incremental operating margin, as much of the cost structure of a trading network is in the fixed upfront costs, which the company can scale against as revenue grows.

Tradeweb’s competitive position is defended by powerful network effects, as the company has built an impressive network of dealers, institutional clients, and retail volume on its platform. As more buyers and sellers use a trading platform, liquidity improves, making the platform a more effective trading tool. More trading volume generally leads to better liquidity, allowing buyers and sellers to enter and exit their positions with less impact on the price of the asset, reducing their implicit trading costs. Additionally, having more users makes finding counterparties easier, reducing trading time and explicit costs as well.

Michael Miller, Morningstar analyst

Fair Isaac FICO

  • Morningstar Rating: ★★★
  • Sector: Technology
  • Industry: Software - Application

Overall, we believe Fair Isaac warrants a narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating. We base this on the firm’s benchmark scores business, which we believe possesses an intangible asset and network effect moat source.

In general, we believe there are two main use cases for FICO scores. The first is to make an underwriting decision for an individual loan. The second is as a benchmark for credit quality among various stakeholders such as originators, investors, analysts, and regulators.

We do not see the underwriting use case as particularly moaty. Many lenders do not use, or do not heavily weigh, FICO scores for their consumer lending decisions. Underwriting is a highly differentiated and often proprietary process for a lender. Capital One, for instance, differentiated itself with an “information-based strategy” that used information technology and sophisticated analytics.

Rajiv Bhatia, Morningstar analyst

MarketAxess Holdings MKTX

  • Morningstar Rating: ★★★
  • Sector: Financial Services
  • Industry: Capital Markets

We assign MarketAxess a Narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating as a result of its position as a leading platform for the electronic trading of US corporate bonds, eurobonds, and emerging market corporate debt, which should allow the firm to continue to outearn its weighted average cost of capital. MarketAxess has benefited significantly from the ongoing transition in fixed-income markets toward electronic trading and away from voice-negotiated trades, leading to rising volume industrywide. This secular trend has provided the company with steady growth as the implicit and explicit cost reductions offered through its trading protocols pull more trading volume to its platform.

However, its competitive position in emerging-market and European debt is noticeably stronger than it is in the US business, where the firm faces falling market share amid encroachment from rival Tradeweb. MarketAxess’ decision to underinvest in portfolio trading and the interdealer market has proved to be a major misstep, as it allowed competitors to enter the US corporate bond market with meaningfully differentiated product offerings. This competitive pressure is offset by MarketAxess’ success in emerging-market debt and eurobonds, where the firm enjoys significant revenue growth thanks to rapidly rising trading volume and less competition. This part of the firm’s business is more competitively defensible thanks to a more fractured user base and lower levels of liquidity across the market. This makes the firm’s network all the more valuable for the traders that use the platform and complicates replication of its network.

Michael Miller, Morningstar analyst

Cheesecake Factory CAKE

  • Morningstar Rating: ★★
  • Sector: Consumer Cyclical
  • Industry: Restaurants

We assign Cheesecake Factory a narrow moat rating, underpinned by a cost advantage. We surmise the firm’s unit-level scale gives it an edge over smaller foes in the fragmented full-service restaurant landscape, where independent establishments account for 63% of the enclave’s total sales. Its namesake banner leverages this edge to offer generous portions, an extensive, hard-to-execute 250-item menu, and an elevated experience at reasonable prices, reliably luring diverse consumers, particularly those drawn to its high-margin cheesecake. This value proposition supports leading average unit volumes by driving persistent traffic to its banners, spreading store-level fixed costs over a larger sales base and bolstering profitability.

In turn, these profits should fund continued investment in its value proposition, reinforcing the virtuous cycle and our expectation for excess returns. While the flagship banner strength supports returns on invested capital, including goodwill, (13%) above our weighted average cost of capital estimate (9%) over the next decade, we stop short of a wide moat rating, as incremental returns on new Cheesecake Factory units across a mature footprint are unlikely to match prior returns, and capital allocated to newer concepts carries risk of value destruction.

More specifically, we’d look to eroding average unit volumes and margins across its existing footprint, new Cheesecake Factory openings consistently falling short of management’s 20%-25% cash-on-cash returns target, and/or lackluster returns from brand scaling of newer shops, which could pull consolidated returns on invested capital below WACC over time.

Ari Felhandler, Morningstar analyst

Read More on Moat Ratings and Morningstar’s Stock Investing Methodology

This article was generated with the help of automation and reviewed by Morningstar editors. Learn more about Morningstar’s use of automation.

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

Sponsor Center